Who Makes Butterscotch Ice Cream? How Good Are They?

Photo of author

Editorial Team

If you’re a fan of sweet and creamy desserts, then butterscotch ice cream is a treat you won’t want to miss. But who makes the best butterscotch ice cream? And what makes their version stand out? Let’s dive into the world of butterscotch ice cream brands and find out!

One popular brand that offers a delicious butterscotch ice cream is Breyers. Known for their high-quality ice creams, Breyers offers a range of flavors including their creamy and indulgent butterscotch. Customers have raved about the taste and quality of Breyers’ butterscotch ice cream, making it a top choice for those craving this classic flavor.

Key Takeaways:

  • Breyers is known for producing high-quality butterscotch ice cream.
  • Customers have given positive reviews about the taste and quality of Breyers’ butterscotch ice cream.

The Legacy of Aglamesis Brothers in Making Butterscotch Ice Cream

Aglamesis Brothers is a renowned ice cream brand that has been making Butterscotch Ice Cream for over a century. They have a rich history and are an integral part of the Cincinnati tradition. Using Old World recipes, wholesome ingredients, and traditional confectionery techniques, Aglamesis Brothers has become synonymous with high-quality ice cream and candies.

Their commitment to excellence has earned them national recognition and numerous accolades. One of their most iconic locations is the Oakley parlor, which is considered one of the last original ice cream parlors from a bygone era. It is a testament to their dedication to preserving the rich tradition of ice cream making.

From their humble beginnings as a small confectionery in the early 1900s, Aglamesis Brothers has grown into a beloved brand known for its exceptional Butterscotch Ice Cream. Their commitment to quality, craftmanship, and attention to detail is evident in every scoop.

When you indulge in Aglamesis Brothers’ Butterscotch Ice Cream, you are not only savoring a delicious treat but also experiencing a taste of history. Their time-honored recipes and commitment to tradition make their ice cream a special and nostalgic experience.

A Homemade Butterscotch Ice Cream Recipe

Making homemade butterscotch ice cream is a delightful and satisfying activity. With just a few simple ingredients, you can create a creamy and decadent treat that will impress your friends and family. Here’s a delicious homemade butterscotch ice cream recipe for you to try:


Ingredients Quantity
Butter 1/2 cup
Brown sugar 1 cup
Whole milk 2 cups
Cornstarch 2 tablespoons
Kosher salt 1/4 teaspoon
Cream cheese 4 ounces
Vanilla extract 1 teaspoon


  1. In a saucepan, melt the butter over medium heat. Add the brown sugar and stir until well combined.
  2. Add the whole milk to the saucepan and whisk until the mixture is smooth.
  3. In a small bowl, mix the cornstarch with a little water to create a slurry.
  4. Pour the cornstarch slurry into the saucepan and whisk vigorously to prevent lumps.
  5. Bring the mixture to a boil, then reduce the heat and simmer for a few minutes until it thickens.
  6. Remove the saucepan from the heat and add the cream cheese and vanilla extract. Whisk until the cream cheese is fully incorporated and the mixture is smooth.
  7. Allow the mixture to cool to room temperature, then refrigerate for at least 4 hours or overnight.
  8. Once chilled, transfer the mixture to an ice cream maker and churn according to the manufacturer’s instructions.
  9. Transfer the churned ice cream to a lidded container and freeze for a few hours or until firm.

Now you have a batch of delicious homemade butterscotch ice cream to enjoy! Serve it in bowls or cones, and feel free to add some additional toppings like crushed butterscotch candies or caramel sauce for extra indulgence.

Homemade Butterscotch Ice Cream

Where to Find Butterscotch Ice Cream Near Me

If you’re craving the creamy sweetness of butterscotch ice cream and wondering where to find it near you, look no further! There are several places where you can satisfy your butterscotch cravings.

Local Ice Cream Shops

Start by checking out your local ice cream shops. These charming establishments often offer a variety of flavors, including the classic butterscotch. Head to your favorite ice cream parlor or explore new ones in your area to discover the best butterscotch ice cream.

Grocery Stores

Don’t forget to visit your nearby grocery stores. Many supermarkets feature a dedicated section for frozen treats, and you’ll likely find a selection of butterscotch ice cream options. Check the ice cream aisle or the freezer section and look for your preferred brand or try something new.

Specialty Dessert Shops

If you’re looking for a unique twist on butterscotch ice cream, specialty dessert shops might have just what you’re after. These establishments are known for their innovative flavors and creations. Whether it’s a butterscotch ripple or a fusion flavor, specialty dessert shops can offer a delightful and unexpected take on butterscotch ice cream.

Popular Ice Cream Chains

Many popular ice cream chains have embraced the timeless appeal of butterscotch. From national favorites to regional gems, these chains often feature butterscotch ice cream flavors on their menus. Check with your local ice cream chain or search online to find out if they serve butterscotch ice cream near you.

Online Food Delivery Services

If you prefer the convenience of enjoying butterscotch ice cream in the comfort of your own home, consider using online food delivery services. You may be able to order your favorite brand or flavor of butterscotch ice cream and have it delivered right to your doorstep. Just a few clicks away from satisfying your butterscotch cravings!

Local Establishments

Aside from the options mentioned above, don’t forget to check with local restaurants, cafes, and dessert shops. They may surprise you with their homemade butterscotch ice cream or unique creations.

With so many places to find butterscotch ice cream near you, you’ll never have to go without this delightful treat. Indulge in the rich and creamy goodness of butterscotch, whether it’s from a local shop or delivered straight to your door.

The Best Butterscotch Ice Cream Brands and Flavors

While Breyers and Aglamesis Brothers are well-known for their butterscotch ice cream, there are other brands and flavors available in the market. Some popular brands include Haagen-Dazs, Talenti, Ben & Jerry’s, and Blue Bell. These brands offer a range of flavors, including traditional butterscotch, butterscotch ripple, butterscotch pecan, and butterscotch swirl. Each brand and flavor has its own unique take on the classic butterscotch flavor, so you can explore and find your favorite.

Comparison of Butterscotch Ice Cream Brands and Flavors

Brand Flavors
  • Traditional butterscotch
  • Butterscotch ripple
  • Butterscotch pecan
  • Butterscotch swirl
Aglamesis Brothers
  • Classic butterscotch
  • Butterscotch ripple
  • Butterscotch sundae
  • Butterscotch caramel
  • Butterscotch swirl
  • Butterscotch and almond
  • Butterscotch and caramel
  • Old-fashioned butter pecan
  • Butterscotch caramel
Ben & Jerry’s
  • Butterscotch blondie
  • Butter pecan
  • Butterscotch swirled with caramel
Blue Bell
  • Homemade vanilla and buttered pecan
  • Butterscotch ripple
  • Butterscotch swirl

Explore these brands to discover the best butterscotch ice cream flavors that suit your taste buds. Whether you prefer a classic butterscotch or a unique twist with added toppings, there is a wide variety to choose from. Try them all and find your personal favorite!

Best Butterscotch Ice Cream


Butterscotch ice cream is a creamy and indulgent treat loved by many. Whether you choose to enjoy a scoop from a renowned brand or try your hand at making homemade butterscotch ice cream, it’s a flavor that is sure to satisfy your sweet tooth. With the wide variety of butterscotch ice cream brands and flavors available, there’s something for everyone to enjoy. So go ahead, treat yourself to a scoop of delicious butterscotch ice cream and savor every bite.


Who makes butterscotch ice cream?

Breyers, Aglamesis Brothers, Haagen-Dazs, Talenti, Ben & Jerry’s, and Blue Bell are some popular brands that make butterscotch ice cream.

What flavors of butterscotch ice cream does Breyers offer?

Breyers offers Creamery Style Chocolate, Creamery Style Natural Vanilla, Creamery Style Neapolitan, Creamery Style French Vanilla, Creamery Style Maple Walnut, Creamery Style Dark Cherry Vanilla, Creamery Style Dark Chocolate Truffle, and Creamery Style Caramel Fudge flavors of butterscotch ice cream.

How long has Aglamesis Brothers been making butterscotch ice cream?

Aglamesis Brothers has been making butterscotch ice cream for over a century.

What is the recipe for homemade butterscotch ice cream?

The homemade butterscotch ice cream recipe calls for butter, brown sugar, whole milk, cornstarch, kosher salt, cream cheese, and vanilla extract. It involves cooking the butterscotch, adding milk and cornstarch, boiling the mixture, and whisking in cream cheese and vanilla.

Where can I find butterscotch ice cream near me?

You can find butterscotch ice cream near you at local ice cream shops, grocery stores, specialty dessert shops, and popular ice cream chains. You can also use online food delivery services to satisfy your craving for butterscotch ice cream.

What are some other butterscotch ice cream brands and flavors?

Some other butterscotch ice cream brands include Haagen-Dazs, Talenti, Ben & Jerry’s, and Blue Bell. These brands offer flavors such as traditional butterscotch, butterscotch ripple, butterscotch pecan, and butterscotch swirl.