Who Makes Spumoni Ice Cream? How Good Are They?

Photo of author

Editorial Team

Spumoni is a traditional Italian dessert known for its delightful mix of flavors and textures. But who are the masterminds behind this delectable treat? Let’s take a closer look at two prominent brands that craft mouthwatering Spumoni ice cream: Brothers Ice Cream and Prairie Farms.

Brothers Ice Cream – A Leading Spumoni Brand

Brothers Ice Cream, based in Orange County, California, is renowned for its high-quality and flavorful ice cream creations. They have perfected the art of making Spumoni ice cream, which features three distinct flavors: pistachio, cherry, and either chocolate or vanilla. Brothers Ice Cream sources the finest ingredients and ensures strict traceability of raw materials, guaranteeing exceptional taste and quality.

What sets Brothers Ice Cream apart is its commitment to natural ingredients. Their products do not contain any artificial additives or preservatives. Additionally, Brothers Ice Cream uses carrageenans derived from red seaweed in their ice cream, which provide gelling, thickening, and stabilizing properties. This attention to detail and emphasis on natural ingredients create a truly indulgent and satisfying Spumoni ice cream experience.



When it comes to safety and compliance, Brothers Ice Cream surpasses industry standards. Their facility participates in annual Good Manufacturing Practices/Food Safety Systems audits and meets FDA requirements. Quarterly inspections by USDA/State of California Department of Food and Agriculture Animal Health and Food Safety Services further ensure product quality. With their dedication to excellence, it’s no wonder that Brothers Ice Cream has become a leading Spumoni brand.

Prairie Farms – A Popular Spumoni Ice Cream Option

Prairie Farms is another well-known brand that offers a delightful Spumoni ice cream experience. Their Spumoni ice cream features a rich combination of cream, milk, sugar, stabilizers, various fruits, cocoa, natural and artificial flavors, and food colorings. Prairie Farms takes pride in creating a seasonal flavor that captures the essence of summertime.

One of the standout features of Prairie Farms’ Spumoni ice cream is its gluten-free nature. While the base ice cream is generally considered gluten-free, it’s worth noting that additives like candied nuts or other mix-ins may contain gluten. For individuals with dietary restrictions, Prairie Farms also offers dairy-free options such as Natural Choice Pints and Bars and Absolute Fruit Sorbet Pints.

Similar to Brothers Ice Cream, Prairie Farms maintains high standards for safety and quality. Their facility undergoes annual audits for Good Manufacturing Practices/Food Safety Systems and complies with FDA’s Current Good Manufacturing Practice (CGMP) requirements. The quarterly inspections by USDA/State of California Department of Food and Agriculture Animal Health and Food Safety Services guarantee that Prairie Farms’ Spumoni ice cream delivers top-notch quality and taste.

Key Takeaways:

  • Brothers Ice Cream and Prairie Farms are renowned brands that offer exceptional Spumoni ice cream.
  • Brothers Ice Cream focuses on natural ingredients, strict traceability, and the use of carrageenans derived from red seaweed.
  • Prairie Farms’ Spumoni ice cream is associated with the summertime and is generally considered gluten-free, although certain mix-ins may contain gluten.
  • Both brands prioritize safety and quality through annual audits and inspections.
  • Individuals with dietary restrictions can enjoy dairy-free options from Prairie Farms.

Now that we know who makes Spumoni ice cream and the quality they deliver, let’s explore more about this unique frozen delight and where you can find it.

Brothers Ice Cream – A Leading Spumoni Brand

When it comes to Spumoni ice cream, one name stands out among the rest – Brothers Ice Cream. As one of the best Spumoni ice cream companies in the market, they have gained a reputation for being an authentic gelato producer with a commitment to quality and taste.

Located in Orange County, California, Brothers Ice Cream operates a state-of-the-art manufacturing facility. This facility not only meets FDA’s Current Good Manufacturing Practice (CGMP) requirements but is also in compliance with the Food Safety Modernization Act (FSMA) regulations. It is certified as a California State Certified Food Processor and Organic Food Processor by Oregon Tilth.

Their dedication to food safety and quality is evident in their rigorous auditing and inspection processes. Brothers International Desserts Inc. undergoes regular audits, including Good Manufacturing Practices, Food Safety Systems audits, FDA compliance, and Kosher certification. This ensures that every product they produce meets the highest industry standards.

Brothers Ice Cream offers a wide variety of flavors, including their signature Spumoni ice cream. Made with love and care, each batch is crafted using the finest ingredients. Some of their recipes may contain nuts such as almond, hazelnut, walnut, pecan nut, macadamia nut, and pistachio, while others may have cereals with gluten. However, they also cater to different dietary preferences by offering dairy-free options like Natural Choice Pints, Bars, and Absolute Fruit Sorbet Pints.

One of the key ingredients in all Brothers Ice Cream recipes is egg yolk, which acts as a natural emulsifier. This helps create a smooth and creamy texture that is characteristic of their gelato. Additionally, they use carrageenan, a food-grade ingredient derived from red seaweed, to enhance the gelling, thickening, and stabilizing properties of their ice cream.

To ensure that their products arrive frozen and in perfect condition, Brothers Ice Cream uses specially designed coolers packed with dry ice. These coolers maintain a temperature of -20 degrees Fahrenheit throughout the shipping process. They offer free shipping to the lower 48 states, with additional options for overnight shipping and shipping to Hawaii and Alaska for an extra fee.

Whether you’re a Spumoni enthusiast or simply love delicious gelato, Brothers Ice Cream is the go-to brand for a truly delightful ice cream experience. Their dedication to quality, flavor, and customer satisfaction sets them apart as a leading Spumoni brand. Try their authentic gelato creations and indulge in the rich, creamy goodness that Brothers Ice Cream has to offer.

Prairie Farms – A Popular Spumoni Ice Cream Option

If you’re a fan of Spumoni ice cream, you’ll be delighted to know that Prairie Farms, a renowned ice cream manufacturer, offers its own delicious version of this classic flavor. As a top Spumoni ice cream supplier, Prairie Farms has made a name for itself in the ice cream industry, delivering exceptional quality and taste.

Prairie Farms’ Spumoni ice cream is carefully crafted using a blend of high-quality ingredients, including fresh cream, milk, and sugar. The result is a creamy and flavorful frozen treat that captivates the taste buds. In addition to the traditional flavors of chocolate, pistachio, and cherry, Prairie Farms’ Spumoni ice cream often incorporates other delightful ingredients, such as almonds or chocolate chips, to enhance the overall taste and texture.

The Perfect Blend of Flavors

What sets Prairie Farms’ Spumoni ice cream apart is its ability to bring together the perfect blend of flavors in every scoop. The rich chocolate, nutty pistachio, and sweet cherry flavors complement each other harmoniously, creating a delightful sensory experience. Each bite offers a symphony of tastes that will leave you craving for more.

Whether you enjoy Spumoni ice cream as a standalone treat or as a complement to your favorite desserts, Prairie Farms’ offering is sure to satisfy your cravings. Their attention to detail and commitment to quality make them a top choice for ice cream enthusiasts across the nation.

If you’re looking to indulge in the authentic flavors of Spumoni ice cream, Prairie Farms is a brand you can trust. Their commitment to crafting premium-quality frozen treats ensures that every bite of their Spumoni ice cream is a true delight.

Homemade Spumoni Ice Cream Recipe

If you prefer to make your own spumoni ice cream at home, here is a simple recipe to try.

Ingredients:

  • 3 cups of pistachio ice cream
  • 3 cups of vanilla (or cherry vanilla) ice cream
  • 1 cup of chopped maraschino cherries
  • 1/3 cup of chopped sliced almonds
  • 2 tablespoons of cherry brandy
  • 1 teaspoon of almond extract
  • A few specks of pink food coloring
  • 3 cups of chocolate ice cream

Instructions:

  1. Soften each flavor of ice cream separately.
  2. In a loaf pan or container, layer the flavors one at a time, starting with pistachio, then cherry, and ending with chocolate or vanilla.
  3. Sprinkle pistachio nuts, maraschino cherries, and chocolate chips (if desired) between each layer.
  4. Freeze the assembled spumoni ice cream for at least 4 hours or until firm.
  5. Serve and enjoy your homemade spumoni ice cream!

What Makes Spumoni Ice Cream Unique?

Spumoni ice cream is known for its unique characteristics that set it apart from traditional ice cream. This delightful frozen dessert originated in Italy and has gained popularity worldwide, especially in countries with large Italian immigrant populations like the United States, Argentina, and Brazil. So, what makes Spumoni so special?

Distinct Flavor Combination

One of the defining features of Spumoni ice cream is its combination of flavors. Typically, it consists of pistachio, cherry, and either chocolate or vanilla, offering a perfect blend of sweet, nutty, and fruity notes. These flavors are carefully selected to create a harmonious taste experience.

Rich Mix-Ins

Another characteristic of Spumoni is the inclusion of various mix-ins that add texture and flavor. It often features mix-ins like fresh or candied fruit, nuts, and sometimes even chocolate pieces or cocoa nibs. These mix-ins offer delightful surprises as you indulge in each spoonful of this frozen treat.

Light and Creamy Texture

Spumoni’s texture sets it apart from traditional ice cream. Made with a base of gelato, it is lighter and airier, giving it a smoother and creamier consistency. Gelato, with a higher proportion of milk and lower proportion of cream and eggs compared to ice cream, churns at a slower pace, resulting in a denser and richer tasting dessert.

Layered Composition

Spumoni is often presented as a layered frozen dessert, with each layer representing a different flavor. The layers of pistachio, cherry, and chocolate (or vanilla) ice cream are separated by freezing times to achieve distinct lines. This layered composition not only adds visual appeal but also enhances the tasting experience.

Versatility and Customizability

Spumoni ice cream offers versatility and customizability. Whether store-bought or homemade, it can be tailored to suit individual preferences. You can choose premium ice cream brands and select different mix-ins, such as fresh or frozen cherries, to create a personalized version of this delightful dessert.

Overall, Spumoni ice cream’s unique characteristics, including its distinct flavor combination, rich mix-ins, light and creamy texture, layered composition, and versatility, make it a wonderful treat to enjoy during hot summer days or as a dessert for special occasions.

Where to Find Spumoni Ice Cream?

If you’re craving a delicious scoop of spumoni ice cream, you’re in luck! There are several places where you can find this delightful Italian dessert. Whether you’re looking for the classic flavors or unique variations, here are some top destinations to satisfy your spumoni cravings:

Italian Specialty Food Stores

When it comes to finding authentic spumoni ice cream, Italian specialty food stores are a great option. These stores often carry a wide range of Italian desserts and treats, including spumoni. You can browse through their selection and choose from different brands and flavors. One highly-rated option is L & B Spumoni Gardens, located in Gravesend. With a rating of 4.2 and 4.7k reviews, you can trust that their spumoni is both delicious and popular.

Gelato Shops

If you’re a fan of gelato, you’ll be pleased to know that many gelato shops offer spumoni as one of their flavors. Known for its rich and creamy texture, gelato provides the perfect base for spumoni’s combination of flavors. Veniero’s, situated in East Village, is a renowned gelato shop with a rating of 4.1 and 2.5k reviews. Their spumoni is sure to delight your taste buds.

Supermarkets

For a convenient option, check out major supermarkets that carry spumoni ice cream. Safeway, for example, is known to stock spumoni from popular brands like Brothers. While the selection may vary, it’s worth checking your local supermarket’s freezer section for this delicious treat.

Online Retailers and Specialty Ice Cream Shops

Thanks to the power of the internet, you can now order spumoni ice cream online and have it delivered right to your doorstep. Online retailers and specialty ice cream shops often offer a wide variety of flavors, including spumoni. This allows you to explore different brands and find the perfect spumoni to satisfy your cravings. When checking out online options, be sure to read reviews and ratings to ensure you’re getting high-quality spumoni.

Wherever you choose to find your spumoni ice cream, you’re in for a treat. With its smooth texture, rich flavors, and beautiful colors, spumoni is a dessert that captivates both the eyes and taste buds. So go ahead, indulge in a scoop or two of this delightful Italian treat!

Is Spumoni Ice Cream Gluten-Free?

Spumoni ice cream is a delicious and popular frozen treat that many people enjoy. If you follow a gluten-free diet, you may be wondering if spumoni ice cream is a safe option for you. The good news is that, in its most basic form, spumoni ice cream is naturally gluten-free.

The base ingredients of spumoni ice cream, such as cream, milk, and sugar, do not contain gluten. This means that if you purchase or make spumoni ice cream using only these ingredients, you can enjoy it without worrying about gluten content.

However, it’s important to note that some spumoni ice creams may include mix-ins or additional flavors that could potentially contain gluten. For example, spumoni ice cream may feature candied nuts or cookies as part of its flavor profile. These mix-ins may introduce gluten into the ice cream.

If you have celiac disease or a gluten intolerance, it’s crucial to read the labels and ingredient lists carefully to ensure that the spumoni ice cream you choose is gluten-free. Look for brands that specifically state that their spumoni ice cream is gluten-free, like Prairie Farms.

By carefully selecting or making your own spumoni ice cream with gluten-free ingredients, you can enjoy this delightful frozen treat without compromising your dietary needs.

Is Spumoni Ice Cream Seasonal?

While spumoni ice cream can be enjoyed throughout the year, it is often associated with the summertime. Many major brands release spumoni ice cream as a limited-time flavor during the warmer months when ice cream consumption is at its peak. However, specialty food stores and gelato shops may offer spumoni year-round, providing ice cream enthusiasts with the opportunity to enjoy this delicious treat regardless of the season.

Spumoni ice cream’s seasonality is deeply rooted in its traditional Italian heritage. The refreshing combination of flavors, including cherry, pistachio, and chocolate or vanilla, makes it a perfect choice for hot summer days. The vibrant colors of the Italian flag – red, green, and white – echo the flavors found in this classic dessert.

According to renowned Chef Cesare Casella, the seasonality of spumoni plays a significant role in its creation. The flavors are carefully selected and sliced, allowing for experimentation and adjustment based on the season’s produce and preferences. This adaptability ensures that spumoni remains a seasonal delight that captures the essence of the changing seasons.

Spumoni ice cream provides a delightful and unique alternative to traditional flavors, making it a sought-after treat during the summer months. The limited-time availability adds to its desirability, creating a sense of anticipation and making those fleeting moments of indulgence even more special.

For those who crave spumoni throughout the year, it is worth exploring specialty food stores, gelato shops, and local ice cream parlors that may offer this Italian delight year-round. While mainstream brands may only release spumoni for a limited time, these establishments cater to the evergreen demand for this beloved frozen treat.

Whether enjoyed on a warm summer day or savored during the cooler months, spumoni ice cream’s seasonality adds to its allure and makes each bite a delectable reminder of the changing seasons.

What is in Spumoni Ice Cream?

Spumoni ice cream is a delightful frozen treat with a unique combination of flavors. While the exact ingredients may vary depending on the brand and recipe, the traditional elements of spumoni include cherry, pistachio, and either chocolate or vanilla ice creams. These layers create a harmonious blend of flavors that is both refreshing and indulgent.

Unlike other ice creams, spumoni offers a delightful contrast of textures and tastes. It incorporates various ingredients, such as cherries, pistachio nuts, and creamy bases, to create a flavorful medley that appeals to the senses.

Some brands and recipes may add additional mix-ins to enhance the flavor and texture of spumoni. These mix-ins can include chocolate chips, candied nuts, or fruit pieces, adding a delightful crunch and burst of sweetness to each bite. The versatility of spumoni allows for creative and unique variations, ensuring there is a flavor combination to suit every palate.

Spumoni Ingredients:

  • Cherry ice cream
  • Pistachio ice cream
  • Chocolate or vanilla ice cream
  • Cherries
  • Pistachio nuts
  • Optional mix-ins (e.g., chocolate chips, candied nuts, fruit)

If you have specific dietary requirements or allergens, it is important to check the ingredient list of the spumoni ice cream to ensure it meets your needs.

To give you a visual representation of the layers and flavors in spumoni ice cream, here is a simplified table:

Layer Flavor
Bottom Chocolate or Vanilla
Middle Pistachio
Top Cherry

Conclusion

Spumoni ice cream is a delicious and unique Italian dessert that combines flavors like pistachio, cherry, and chocolate or vanilla. Whether you choose a renowned brand like Brothers or Prairie Farms or decide to make your own at home, spumoni ice cream is a delightful treat for ice cream lovers.

With its three layers of different flavored gelato and the addition of candied fruits like cherries, orange peel, and chopped pistachios, spumoni presents a beautiful and vibrant dessert option. Its light and airy texture, derived from the Italian word “spuma,” adds to the overall appeal of this timeless treat.

First originating in Naples, Italy, in the 18th century, spumoni has gained popularity around the world, including the United States, where it was introduced by Italian immigrants. Its versatility makes it suitable for all seasons and various settings, from special occasions to everyday enjoyment.

One establishment that has been serving delicious spumoni ice cream for over a century is Angelo Brocato’s Italian Ice Cream Parlor. The reopening of this beloved shop, which offers flavors like Zuppa inglese, amaretto, and stracciatella, brought joy and relief to both locals and visitors from miles away.

FAQ

Who Makes Spumoni Ice Cream? How Good Are They?

Spumoni ice cream is made by various brands, including Brothers and Prairie Farms. The quality and taste of these brands may vary, so it is recommended to try different ones to find your favorite.

What Makes Spumoni Ice Cream Unique?

Spumoni ice cream stands out for its unique characteristics. It is a combination of flavors, usually pistachio, cherry, and either chocolate or vanilla. The flavors are distinct and complement each other well. Spumoni also often includes mix-ins like candied nuts, fruit, and sometimes chocolate chips. Its light and airy texture sets it apart from regular ice cream, giving it a smooth and creamy consistency.

Where to Find Spumoni Ice Cream?

Spumoni ice cream can be found in various places. Italian specialty food stores are a great option to find authentic spumoni, as well as gelato shops that offer a variety of flavors. Some major supermarkets like Safeway may also carry spumoni ice cream from brands like Brothers. Additionally, online retailers and specialty ice cream shops often offer spumoni ice cream for delivery.

Is Spumoni Ice Cream Gluten-Free?

The base ingredients of spumoni ice cream, such as cream, milk, and sugar, are naturally gluten-free. However, some spumoni ice creams may contain mix-ins like candied nuts or cookies that could contain gluten. It is important to read the labels and ingredient lists carefully to ensure that the spumoni ice cream you choose is gluten-free, especially if you have celiac disease or a gluten intolerance. Some brands, like Prairie Farms, offer gluten-free options.

Is Spumoni Ice Cream Seasonal?

While spumoni ice cream can be enjoyed throughout the year, it is often associated with the summertime. Many major brands release spumoni ice cream as a limited-time flavor during the warmer months when ice cream consumption is at its peak. However, specialty food stores and gelato shops may offer spumoni year-round, providing ice cream enthusiasts with the opportunity to enjoy this delicious treat regardless of the season.

What is in Spumoni Ice Cream?

The exact ingredients of spumoni ice cream vary depending on the brand and recipe. However, the typical ingredients include cream, milk, sugar, pistachio nuts, maraschino cherries, and either chocolate or vanilla flavoring. Some brands may also add mix-ins like chocolate chips, candied nuts, or fruit for added texture and flavor. It is important to check the ingredient list for any allergens or specific dietary requirements.